The Friday evening summons
Every year, there should be one weekend when the ordinary world gives way to Middle-earth. Friends arrive on Friday evening carrying overnight bags, blankets and an unreasonable quantity of snacks. Someone has brought a loaf of bread; someone else is already arguing about which film contains the best moment. The lights are low, the television has been tested, the discs are lined up in order, and there is a shared understanding that nobody has somewhere more important to be. This is the ideal Lord of the Rings marathon: theatrical edition, then extended edition, then the making-of material, repeated for each of Peter Jackson’s three films. It is a small film festival, a sleepover and an annual act of devotion to the extraordinary undertaking that brought Tolkien’s world to the screen.
The opening ceremony begins with a number. Tolkien died in 1973, on 2 September. Read those four digits another way and they make the distribution of the Rings of Power: one Ring for the Dark Lord, nine for mortal Men, seven for the Dwarf-lords and three for the Elven-kings. The order in the familiar verse is three, seven, nine and one, but 1-9-7-3 gives the weekend its wonderfully nerdish password. The host announces that preparations commence at 19:73. Of course, no clock actually displays 19:73. Seventy-three minutes after 19:00 is 20:13, or 8:13 p.m. That is the real, precise moment to bring out the first course, switch on the lamps and declare the marathon open. The first film begins at 9:00 p.m. sharp.
The rule of the three viewings
The theatrical editions go first, always. That is the central principle. The familiar suggestion to watch only the extended cuts overlooks a remarkable part of these films’ history: three films were shaped for cinema audiences, projected in darkened rooms in 2001, 2002 and 2003, and experienced as complete works in their original form. The theatrical Fellowship is a lesson in economy and escalation, beginning in the Shire and moving almost imperceptibly toward terror. The Two Towers finds a rhythm among several separate journeys. The Return of the King carries a vast conclusion through a series of emotional resolutions. Their editorial decisions deserve to be encountered on their own terms.
For that first screening, everyone agrees to near silence. No phones, no running commentary, no jokes rehearsed from twenty previous viewings. Laughter at a funny line is welcome; an involuntary gasp remains part of watching a film. Conversation waits. The room belongs to the score, the performances, the sound design and the movement of the images. If anyone needs the bathroom, use the credits or the break between editions. Food should already be within reach. This is the ceremonial watch, and it should feel as concentrated as a cinema screening.
Then, without abandoning the film, comes its extended edition. Think of the difference as returning to a country immediately after seeing its principal roads: now we take the woodland paths, stop in the villages and meet people whom the faster journey passed by. Fellowship gains the warmth of the Concerning Hobbits material, the elves’ departure and further time with the Fellowship. The Two Towers gives its characters additional memory, humour and political texture. The Return of the King restores more of the Houses of Healing, Faramir and Éowyn, and the confrontation with the Mouth of Sauron. The extended viewing can be more companionable, with a few whispered observations, but it remains a complete and uninterrupted screening, not a collection of favourite clips.
Only after both versions have played does the curtain lift on the filmmaking. This is the third movement of each day. The Appendices are a second epic, a patient record of writing, casting, costume-making, practical effects, miniatures, location filming, editing, sound and Howard Shore’s music. The Fellowship material explains how the seemingly impossible project acquired its shape. The Two Towers material follows the creation of Gollum and the immense physical and digital labour behind Helm’s Deep. The Return of the King material watches an exhausted company carry its story to the finish. Here, discussion is encouraged. The sofa becomes a screening room and a tiny film school.
The arithmetic of an actual marathon
The timings matter because the word marathon is usually used far too casually. On commonly listed disc runtimes, the theatrical films last 178, 179 and 201 minutes. Their extended counterparts last about 228, 235 and 263 minutes when the additional fan-club credits are included. That makes six complete presentations totalling 21 hours and 24 minutes before a single documentary starts. Some databases quote shorter extended runtimes because they omit those long fan-credit sequences; for a disc-based marathon, it is sensible to budget the full playback time.
The famous 15-disc extended-edition Blu-ray collection advertises more than 26 hours of additional material, including the six Appendices programmes and Costa Botes’s remarkable candid documentaries. Those extras alone are longer than the six film screenings. Together, the films and the advertised bonus material exceed 47 hours of watching. Multiple feature-length audio commentaries, galleries and interactive features are another layer again. If ‘every single extra’ means every commentary played from beginning to end as well, one weekend is simply insufficient. The honest version of the plan gives the documentary programmes their own time and treats the commentary tracks as a separate, even longer annual expedition.
|
Film |
Theatrical |
Extended |
Both cuts |
|
The Fellowship of the Ring |
2 h 58 m |
3 h 48 m |
6 h 46 m |
|
The Two Towers |
2 h 59 m |
3 h 55 m |
6 h 54 m |
|
The Return of the King |
3 h 21 m |
4 h 23 m |
7 h 44 m |
Disc playback timings include the longer extended-edition fan credits. Exact runtimes vary slightly by release.
Three films across the weekend
Friday belongs to The Fellowship of the Ring, beginning at nine in the evening, just after the 20:13 ritual. Its theatrical cut reaches the credits shortly before midnight. The extended film then carries everyone into the small hours, and the first two Appendices, with the Fellowship instalment of the Costa Botes footage, take the gathering through Saturday morning. There is no shame in greeting sunrise with discussions of forced perspective, Hobbit feet and the labour of making the Shire real. At the end of that block, close the curtains, eat a proper meal and sleep. A marathon is improved by people who remain capable of appreciating what they are seeing.
Saturday late afternoon belongs to The Two Towers. The theatrical film is shown with the same concentrated quiet. The extended film follows it, deepening the tragedy at Osgiliath, the memory of Boromir and the humanity of the Rohirrim. The documentaries then take over the night. By the time the making of Helm’s Deep has unfolded, the audience has effectively watched a second siege being fought behind the camera, by stunt performers, armourers, sound editors, animators and a production crew attempting the unprecedented. The next rest comes on Sunday morning.
Sunday afternoon launches The Return of the King. There should be a real dinner beforehand, not a bowl of crisps pretending to be a meal. The theatrical film is the last ceremonial screening: everyone quiet for the Ride of the Rohirrim, the climb toward Mount Doom and the long farewell. The extended cut follows, in its full four-hour-plus splendour. Then come the final Appendices and the behind-the-scenes record of an enormous creative company saying goodbye. This is where the marathon earns its name. On a strict documentaries-complete plan, the final credit is likely to arrive early on Monday morning. A Sunday-night finish is possible only by drastically reducing rest, cutting supplements or beginning the festival earlier than Friday evening.
A workable long weekend timetable
|
When |
The plan |
|
Friday 20:13 |
Food and gathering ritual; theatrical Fellowship begins at 21:00 |
|
Friday 21:00 to Saturday 12:30 |
Fellowship theatrical, then extended, then roughly nine hours of its documentary supplements |
|
Saturday 12:30 to 17:30 |
Meal, shower and proper rest |
|
Saturday 17:30 to Sunday 09:10 |
Two Towers theatrical, extended and documentary supplements |
|
Sunday 09:10 to 14:10 |
Breakfast and rest |
|
Sunday 14:10 to Monday 06:40 |
Return of the King theatrical, extended and documentary supplements |
The supplementary blocks are approximate planning allowances, not published per-film runtimes. This is an extreme timetable with short rest windows; extend into Monday for a genuinely comfortable gathering.
Food fit for the road
A true marathon needs a kitchen plan as carefully prepared as the disc order. Friday begins with a generous supper, a plate of vegetables and savoury pastries, or a pot of stew that can feed visitors as they settle in. There should be bread, cheese, fruit, nuts and plenty of water ready before the theatrical cut starts. Put the loud packaging away. Make hot drinks during the changeover. The rule is simple: food supports the experience, and nobody should have to interrupt the quiet screenings to negotiate a delivery.
Saturday morning offers a second breakfast after Fellowship, perhaps eggs, mushrooms, toast and tea. Lunch is something cooked ahead, and the proper Saturday evening meal honours Rohan with roast vegetables, potatoes and a hearty shared dish. Sunday asks for the most impressive table, preferably before Gondor’s last battle begins: soup, good bread, a substantial main course, something sweet and enough leftovers for the last stretch. Name the breaks if you wish: elevenses, afternoon tea, supper. The joke has endured because hobbits understand the social architecture of a meal. Still, allow people to eat what suits them, take water and sleep adequately. No fictional kingdom is improved by a room of miserable, dehydrated guests.
The ending of the road
The best arrangement is for guests to clear the whole long weekend, with Monday morning held in reserve for the conclusion and a proper rest afterwards. If everyone must leave by Sunday evening, the perfectly respectable variation is to show all six cuts but select documentary chapters for each film, saving the remaining material for future nights. What makes the true version distinctive is its sequence, its respect for the theatrical experience, and its insistence that the making of the films is part of the story of the films themselves. The schedule should bend to human beings; the order should remain sacred.
Finally, when the making-of films end and the room falls quiet, there is no need to fill the silence immediately. Think of the hundreds of people who built this world, the actors who gave it their bodies and voices, and the author who died in 1973 without seeing its cinematic incarnation. The sleepers are still scattered around the lounge. The table holds the remains of three days of hospitality. Someone gathers the discs and places them back in their cases, one by one. An ordinary weekend has acquired a shape and a memory. Next year, at precisely 20:13 on a Friday, the road will go ever on.
Sources for the timings and archive
The Tolkien Estate, Biography (tolkienestate.com/life/biography/), for the date of Tolkien’s death.
Warner and Roadshow release listings through Cinema Vault (cinemavault.com.au), for the theatrical and extended releases and the 15-disc set’s more than 26 hours of bonus content.
National Library of New Zealand, The Lord of the Rings Motion Picture Trilogy catalogue (natlib.govt.nz/records/21004444), for the six Appendices and commentary contents.


